Home » Bad Arguments

August 2022

Forcing Religious Claims Part 2: Rejecting Autonomy Arguments Doesn’t Require Religion

By |2022-08-16T19:22:03+00:00August 16th, 2022|Categories: Critique, Humanity, PRO LIFE|Tags: , , |

In the last post we discussed just who in the abortion argument is forcing odd views of human value on whom. Pro-life claims enjoy at least two obvious advantages over views supporting abortion which dehumanize the embryo and fetus; they are more simple claims and more inclusive claims. Neither of these advantages is dependent [...]

April 2022

What Attorney Mary Ziegler Gets Wrong About Pro-Life Tactics (Postmodern Realities Podcast)

By |2022-04-21T18:05:07+00:00April 21st, 2022|Categories: Interview, NEWS, PRO LIFE|Tags: , |

The New York Times recently published an opinion essay from Mary Zigler, Florida State University law professor and author of “Abortion and the Law in America: Roe v. Wade to the Present" titled, “Anti-Abortion Groups Once Portrayed Women as Victims. That’s Changing.” Ziegler claims that opponents of legal abortion have gravitated away from offering legislation grounded in arguments framing women as additional victims of abortion.

January 2022

Won’t the aborted go straight to heaven, because of the age of accountability?

By |2022-01-03T17:56:47+00:00January 14th, 2022|Categories: Critique, Questions|Tags: , |

Emailed Question: I believe that children who die before the age of accountability will go straight to heaven and spend eternity with God. There can be no greater happiness and no greater 'good' than spending eternity in heaven. After the age of accountability, I believe one must ask forgiveness of sins and accept Jesus Christ [...]

December 2021

Won’t the child be worse off if it’s not terminated?

By |2022-01-03T17:57:29+00:00December 31st, 2021|Categories: Critique, Humanity, Questions|Tags: , , |

Emailed question: Think about the life that a baby will most likely lead if born to a mother who was forced to carry the child to term because abortion was illegal. This mother wanted to kill the child, so isn't there a high likelihood that the unwanted child will suffer neglect and abuse at the hands of [...]

May 2021

Both Ugly and Wrong

By |2021-05-17T16:53:08+00:00May 17th, 2021|Categories: Critique, Persuasion, PRO LIFE, Science|Tags: , , , , , |

Is the RU-486 method of abortion any less cruel or "humane" than other forms of Abortion? Has abortion become safer and safer for women, undermining the point that abortion is dangerous? If abortion becomes increasingly private and less open to the charges of being gruesome and ugly, do these claims hold up to scrutiny? Does Jessica Valenti misunderstand or misrepresent the pro-life position?

Go to Top